Schools Visits To Outdoor Education Centres

Every year, many teachers bring their classes to various outdoor education and/or adventure centres throughout the country.
What standards should teachers expect from these centres?
Is there an organisation which overseas the activities of these centres?
What criteria must a centre satisfy in order to be approved?
In this document, I aim to:

Each adventure sport has a governing body. These governing bodies have devised safety standards, working practices and training programmes for their respective sports. It is reasonable to expect that a centre should satisfy the criteria set by the governing bodies when a school group is present.

The standards of good practice set down by the Governing Bodies have taken the following into consideration.

In Ireland there are many "Canoe Clubs", Mountaineering Clubs etc. but the standards mentioned in this document are geared towards Outdoor Education and Adventure Centres that provide leadership and instructional services in an educational or tourist environment.

Most school children will receive their first introduction to adventure sports in Centres of this kind. Their perception of adventure sports will influence public perception. If standards are not maintained, these Centres will not survive and the growth of adventure sports will be stunted. This should be encouraging to teachers and parents alike as they ponder on the wisdom of bringing a group to an Adventure and/or Outdoor Education Centre.

The National Governing Bodies are:

Before availing of any service, we always look for some identifiable mark of quality - ISO in business, Bórd Fáilte Approval in Accommodation etc. The Association for Adventure Sports (AFAS) in Ireland requires the Centre Standards Board to administer an approval scheme for adventure activity providers.

The standards drawn up are accepted as minimum standards by the Dept. of Education and Bórd Fáilte Éireann.
This document is to give you an idea what to expect from Centres - it should not be taken as definitive or legally precise.

The Approval Scheme
The aim of the approval scheme for professional providers of adventure activities is to safeguard members of the public who avail of the professional services of centres and other providers of adventure activities. The means by which this aim is achieved is to ensure that such providers operate according to recommended standards of safety and good practice.

Safety Statement
Each Centre should have a safety statement, which has considered all aspects of their operation. It is expected that the Safety Statement will comply with the requirements of The Safety Health and Welfare at Work Act 1989.

Operations Manual
Every Centre should have an Operations Manual, which works in co-existence with the safety statement. Contained within should be details of procedures followed for each adventure activity - from the time the instructor assumes control of the group until the end of the session. It is unreasonable to expect that these procedures will spell out mechanically what will happen for each session. Adventure Sports imply, by their name alone, that there is an element of discovery and uncertainty of outcome.

The manual will deal comprehensively with such things as:

Each provider or centre will have its own local conditions and hazards and should approach the preparation of the manual with this in mind.

Activities
Activities should be run in accordance with guidelines laid down by the relevant National Governing Bodies.

Crucial considerations include:

Approval
The Centre Standards Board will consider monitor's reports in September of each year and at any other time it deems necessary. Certificate of Approval
When the Board grants approval, a certificate to this affect will be issued. The provider will display this certificate in a public place where clients and members of the public can readily see it. Monitors will check that this is done.


Bórd Oiliúnt Sléibhe- Irish Mountain Training Board
The following standards are laid down by Bórd Oiliúnt Sléibhe (BOS) on behalf of the Mountaineering Council of Ireland (MCI). These are the minimum requirements for Centre operations. Instructors and organisations bringing groups into the hills on a commercial or training basis. Additional standards apply when BOS training schemes are being run.

1. Staffing Qualifications

2. Trainee Candidates 3. Frst Aid A current full REC (Rescue and Emergency Care) award or its equivalent is necessary to validate all mountaineering qualifications. 1. Staffing Ratios 2. Equipment
    Participants and Instructors in hillwalking and Rockclimbing activities must be suitably equipped.

    Due to the changeable nature of our weather, it is difficult to forecast the type of clothing required. The main aim is to have clothing, which will keep water out and heat in. Fortunately, there are a wide variety of "fleece" garments on the market and are an essential part of most peoples' wardrobes. Children and teenagers will not be upset, therefore, to be told that they should wear a fleece garment out on the hills if this is possible. These garments draw moisture away from the skin and thus reduce the risk of children getting cold and miserable even on a wet day. However, a waterproof layer - breathable if possible should cover the fleece layer. Most Centres provide loose waterproof jackets with generous hoods and these do the job admirably - even if they will not be modelled at any fashion show. Check with Centres regarding same before your visit.

    Cotton is a poor performer in the outdoors because it soaks up and retains a lot of moisture. If all this soaked moisture gets cold and is near the skin, the children will be quite miserable in a short space of time. Fleece Tracksuits are a far better alternative both for durability and insulation. Robust footwear is advisable - ankle support and a good solid sole. At the same time, most groups who use the Centres are only there for one day so it is unreasonable to expect that they should have to purchase proper boots to go hill walking or Rockclimbing. The Centres should be equally reasonable when considering the terrain the group must cover.

Irish Surfing Association
The Irish Surfing Association's Approval Scheme for School/Centre produced in association with the European Surfing Federation, outlines standards to ensure safe and enjoyable participation by the public at Schools/Centres who professionally offer instruction or holidays in surfing.

Requirements:
Insurance
The Centre must be covered by public liability insurance for claims by 3rd parties for injury or damage arising out of the operators business of giving surfing lessons.

Qualifications
All surfing instructors must be ISA/ESF Level I qualified instructors. A qualified instructor must supervise Trainees/assistant instructors.

Ratios
Each qualified instructor may instruct a maximum of 8 pupils in the water.

Names
The names of surfing instructors must be sent to the Centre Standards Board prior to the start of each season.

Boards
Students being taught by ISA/ESF Level 1 Coaches must use soft skimmed surfboards. These are boards with foam coating so that possible injuries are reduced should a board hit the child.

Leashes
All surfboards must be equipped with suitable leashes. These are straps attached to the surfers ankle and the board so that when (not if) the surfer falls off the board, they can get to it quickly.

Wetsuits
Appropriate wetsuits must be made available to all students. Under no circumstances should any member of the group have to surf without a wetsuit such is the temperature of the Ocean. The neoprene material in the wetsuit will keep them warm in the water and thus they can concentrate on the activity and not on how cold and miserable they have become. Under the wetsuits, children should wear a swimming costume and a T-shirt.

Maintenance
All equipment must constantly be kept in good repair.

Life-saving
Each instructor will have a life saving aid at hand whilst pupils are in the water.

First Aid
A first aid kit must be available at the beach.

Locations
All beaches used must be suitable for teaching novices to surf and instructors must be aware of the possible hazards at these beaches.

Access
A public roadway must come within easy carry distance from the surfing area in event of an emergency.

Communications
Beaches must be served by public phone or instructors must have a direct communication link (e.g. mobile phone, mobile radio) for emergency use.
Children really enjoy the exhilaration of lying onto a surfboard, swimming against the oncoming waves, turning for shore, working up speed again and feeling the rush of the wave as it carries them to shore. After they get used to the procedure, they will of course try to mimic the actions of the surfers on television and try to stand on the board.

Many people have concerns regarding the sea and justifiably so. The surfing lesson should be held on a safe beach with no unusual currents and the children should all be within quick reach of an instructor.

Irish Amateur Archery Association
The following are the minimum requirements for outdoor activity centres and places where archery is taught to the general public.
1. Staffing
One full time staff member must hold the IAAA Basic Instruction & Safety Certificate. This person shall have responsibility for the shoot range and equipment and shall also be responsible for monitoring the actions of trainee instructors.
 

2. Staffing Ratios
One full time staff member who holds the IAAA Basic Instruction & Safety Certificate must control the shooting range. One other instructor is required to teach the students. The ratio of students to instructors is to be a maximum of 4:1, (the students may be taken in groups of 4).
 

3. Qualifications
Title of qualification Requirements
Basic Instruction & Safety IAAA Certificate (One month as a trainee followed by written exam.
Trainee Instructor IAAA Basic Instruction & Safety

4. Equipment
Bow: Check daily for frayed strings, cracked limbs or cracked riser, if any cracks are found consult professional before using the bow.
Arrows: Check daily for loose fletchings, damaged nocks or bent shafts. Repair as necessary.
Targets: Made from any material suitable to stop arrows without damage.
Arm Guards: Protects student's arm form abrasion by the string.
Whistle: To control shooting.
Shooting Line: All students must be standing on this line before drawing a bow or placing an arrow in the box.
Range: To be laid out to comply to IAAA rules.
Raised Platform: Required so that the person in charge of the range can be seen over the students head and over the top of the targets.
Safety Net: Required when there is not enough clear ground behind the targets.
Watch out for damaged targets - all children should stand behind the shooting line - free from risk of being hit by stray arrows.

Irish Canoe Union Training and Development Unit
The following standards are the minimum requirements considered necessary by the Irish Canoe Union for those involved in providing canoeing in centres.

For clarity, a kayak is a "closed" boat. The occupant sits into the boat and most of their legs will be covered by the top of the boat. A canoe is an open boat - similar in design to an "Indian" canoe. Sometimes the terms are used inappropriately and in the wrong context.

Staffing
1. The overall Director/Organiser should be a registered Level 3 Instructor with the Irish Canoe Union or have an equivalent level qualification in another Adventure sport with at least six months full time instructing experience. It is the responsibility of the Director/Organiser to ensure that all courses are run in accordance with current safety recommendations as laid out by the Irish Canoe Union.

2. Preferably the person either employed or assigned to the centre with responsibility of supervising canoeing activities should hold a current Level 3 Instructor Qualification or higher. However the minimum instructing qualification considered necessary for basis canoeing courses is a Level 1 Instructor Qualification. Holders of this Award must restrict activities to flat inland water or harbours considered suitable by the Irish Canoe Union. Only qualified staff with a minimum of Level 1 Kayak Instructor Qualification should be directly involved in the organisation and running of canoeing sessions.

3. The above criteria refer to the organisation of basic canoeing sessions only. A centre aiming to offer advanced courses in leadership/instruction training must use a full or part time member of staff holding the appropriate Level of Qualification and must have as a minimum the Level 3 Instructor Qualification.

Staffing Ratios Irish Canoe Union Ratios
Inland Ratios
 
Award
Maximum

Ratios which cannot be exceeded

Craft Type
Notes on Ratios
Operating Location
Level 1 Kayak Instructor
Instructor: Participant Ratio of 1:6
Kayaks
The Level 1 Kayak Instructor is restricted to stationary sessions. The Level 1 Kayak Instructor is specifically not qualified to lead journeys
Flat Water/Static Sessions only
Level 2 Kayak Instructor
Instructor: Participant

Ratio of 1:6

Kayaks
The Level 2 Kayak Instructor may instruct and lead groups on flat slow moving water such as grade one rivers or on sheltered lakes.
Flat Water 
Level 3 Kayak Instructor
Instructor: Participant

Ratio of 1:8

Kayaks
On flat on slow moving water such as grade 1 rivers or on lakes which are sheltered.
Flat Water
Level 3 or 4 or 5 Kayak

Instructor

Instructor: Participant

Ratio of 1:6

Kayaks
It should be noted that this ratio depends on the ability of the participants and may need to be lowered. It is advisable that another experienced canoeist accompanies an instructor on moving water sessions as an assistant.
Grade II Rivers - not for beginners on their first day ever in a boat.
Level 4 & 5 Kayak Instructor
Instructor: Participant

Ratio of 1:3

Kayaks
On grade III plus rivers it is strongly recommended that participants hold a Level 4 Kayak Proficiency or higher. Due to the nature of rivers of grade 3 plus it is recommended that Instructors undertake trips that are commensurate with their level of experience and the level of experience of the group.
Grade III+

It is recommended that regardless of group size, at least two instructors are present on the water. It is also recommended that for safety reasons, any single group should not exceed 16 participants.

Open Canoeing Ratios
 
Award
Maximum

Ratios which cannot be

Exceeded

Craft Type
Notes of Ratios
Operating

Location

Level 1 Canoe Instructor
Instructor: Participant Ratio of 1:6
Open Canoes
A maximum of 4 Open Canoes in any combination is permissible provided the Level 1 Canoe Instructor: Participant ratio is not be exceeded. The Level 1 Canoe Instructor is specifically not qualified to lead groups on journeys.
Flat Water/Static

Sessions only

Level 2 Canoe Instructor 
Instructor: Participant Ratio of 1:6
Open Canoes
A maximum of 4 Open Canoes in any combination is permissible provided the Level 2 Canoe Instructor: Participant ratio is not be exceeded. The Level 2 Canoe Instructor is qualified to lead and instruct on flat slow moving water e.g. Grade one water and sheltered lakes.
Grade 1 Water
Level 3 Canoe Instructor
Instructor: Participant Ratio of 1:8

(for Flat Water)

Instructor: Participant Ratio of 1:6

(for Moving Water)

Open Canoes
The Level 3 Canoe Instructor is qualified to lead and instruct on water up to Grade 2 river and on lakes. This ratio covers a maximum of 8 participants and 4 open canoes on flat water. On moving water and on Lakes the ratios cover a maximum of 6 participants and 3 open canoes.
Up to Grade 2

Water

Level 4 or 5 Canoe Instructor
Instructor: Participant Ratio of 1:4
Open Canoes
This ratio covers a maximum of 4 participants and 2 open canoes on grade 2 plus river and lakes.
Grade 2 plus

Rivers

The Irish Canoe Union recommends that open canoes not be taken on the sea except within harbours.

Equipment

Canoeing and Kayaking cast a spell on a multitude of spectators and are disciplines that a lot of people can enjoy - even if they are not very active on land. Beginners should be given a chance to get their balance in the boat and so their first lesson should be on flat water.

Every child should be provided with a wetsuit. Wetsuits are made from neoprene, which is synthetic rubber filled with air bubbles. The material soaks a certain amount of water and after a short time the wearer heats the water which has been absorbed. Over the wetsuit, the child should wear a cagoule - normally called a "cag". This is essentially a windbreaker so that the wind does not chill the water soaked by the wetsuit. Over the "cag" goes the buoyancy aid, which should fit snugly. It is important that the buoyancy aid does not come off the child if the boat capsizes and they are in the water.

Every child should have a helmet as protection from the inexperienced paddlers all around them and should they fall into the water, there may be rocks under the surface.
A pair of old runners should be worn to protect the feet and also to provide limited insulation. You should be satisfied that all children are equipped fully.

Irish Orienteering Association Training & Coaching Board
Guidelines for Approval to run Basic Orienteering 1998
The following standards are the minimum requirements for Outdoor Centres individual instructors or other organisations who wish to organise basic orienteering courses of an introductory nature.

1. Staffing

2. Staffing Ratios
    The recommended Instructor: Student ratio is a minimum of one instructor to ten participants.
3. Equipment & Facilities Orienteering, sometimes called "cunning running" is a tremendous sport which combines the mental agility of map reading under pressure to find clues with the endurance of cross country running. Children enjoy the sport especially when the terrain is easily negotiated and the clues are relatively easy to find. If the clues are proving difficult to find and the child is not experiencing success, it is common to see the heads drop and they simply give up.

A tracksuit and runners are the items of clothing required for this sport.
For a full days activity, the children should come equipped with the following:

(Most Centres will advise you at any rate).